Game of Thrones plot hole: Glaring error in Robb Stark’s revenge plan exposed
15th July 2020

We will use your email address only for sending you newsletters. Please see our Privacy Notice for details of your data protection rights.

Robb Stark was one of the most powerful characters in the earlier seasons of Game of Thrones and could have been a viable ruler of Westeros. Unfortunately, as the HBO series went on, fans agreed his plan to avenge the death of his father was poorly executed.


The eldest son of Ned Stark (played by Sean Bean) was named the new King in the North when his father was executed at the end of season one.

Robb Stark (Richard Madden) waged war against the Lannisters and managed to secure victory in several decisive battles.

Unfortunately, he eventually succumbed to his power-hungry rivals and was killed during the events of the Red Wedding.

Despite the Lannisters gaining the upper-hand, most viewers considered Robb Stark a worthy successor to his father.


  • Winds of Winter release date: When is Winds of Winter coming out?

Had the series panned out differently, the wise and resourceful King in the North could have taken control over the Iron Throne.

However, as some fans have pointed out, his pathway to power was blighted by his motive for revenge.

One Game of Thrones expert took to Screenrant and outlined the numerous problems with Robb’s plan throughout his tenure in the first three seasons.

They explained: “Robb was surely, and rightly so, outraged by his father’s execution. However, Robb had absolutely no game plan outside of avenging his father.

“He wanted his sister back, and he wanted the Lannisters to let the North be its own.”

Ned Stark’s execution was ordered by the vile Joffrey Baratheon (Jack Gleeson) in season one, but was also desperate to rescue his sister Sansa (Sophie Turner).

Sansa Stark was initially betrothed to marry Joffrey, but became a long-suffering hostage of the Lannisters when her father is charged with treason.

Had Robb not been fuelled solely by his desire to get one over on the Lannisters, he may have eventually become a wise and generous ruler.

NCIS season 18 theories: McGee’s sister Sarah makes shock return
Vikings showrunner Michael Hirst reveals why Lagertha had to die [INTERVIEW]
Lucifer season 5 theories: Lucifer’s brother Michael rules over Earth [INSIGHT]

The article continued by arguing Robb’s desire for revenge made him just as nefarious as the Lannisters.

They said: “He didn’t think about supplies, how he would run his new kingdom, or really anything else besides winning a few battles and proving he was a decent leader. Was he the most power hungry of them all?”

Screenrant went on to explain Robb’s careless judgement eventually lost Winterfell during the War of the Five Kings.

They continued: “He has won three battles, but he loses stake in his home territory.”


  • Game of Thrones plot hole: Dothraki error leaves fans stumped

“Also, did anyone else forget that he left Bran, a physically disabled child, in charge?

“It’s no wonder that Bran and Rickon were ‘killed’. And even after this fake news, Robb didn’t do much about it.”

After season eight’s controversial finale, many aspects of Game of Thrones’ convoluted narrative have been criticised in retrospect.

Thankfully, Robb star Richard Madden was able to overcome these hurdles, and has since landed roles in Hollywood films such as Rocketman and Marvel’s The Eternals.

Game of Thrones seasons 1-8 are available to stream on NowTV.

This article contains affiliate links, we may receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more

Source: Read Full Article